• about USAID CIDI
  • the scoop
    • Social Media
    • Good Intentions Newsroom
  • tools for giving
    • Individuals
    • Organizations
    • Donations Registry
    • Share Your Donations Stories
  • how disaster relief works
    • Guidelines for Giving
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Smart Compassion
    • Why Cash Is Best
    • In-Kind Can Be Unkind
    • Greatest Good Donation Calculator
  • disaster responses
    • Peru Floods
    • Lake Chad Basin Crisis
    • Horn of Africa Crisis
    • Iraq Crisis
    • South Sudan Crisis
    • Syria Crisis

Best practices often lose out to quick and cheap programs that please donors

July 29, 2014 by GoodIntentions in Administration Costs, Choosing a charity, Common aid problems, Good Intentions

Donations can be misused and ill-spent despite the best intentions of donors
Deciding whether or not to donate and which agency or project to donate to can be a daunting and frustrating task. Although donors choose aid agencies that they think will have the greatest impact, aid donations often are misused and ill-spent. This occurs both despite of and because of the best intentions of donors.

How does this happen?
Concerned about aid reaching those who need it the most, many donors give to aid agencies that work quickly and cheaply. Dependent upon donors for funding and survival, aid agencies feel pressured to develop programs that are fast and cheap. Unfortunately, projects with low administration costs and fast implementation rates often have unintended consequences.

Best practices that often lose out to faster and cheaper practices include:

  • Enabling aid recipients to be active decision makers in the aid they receive
  • Conducting a needs assessment to determine the type of aid needed and where it is needed the most before developing interventions
  • Cooperating with the local government to ensure that their work is supported and not undermined by aid efforts
  • Coordinating with other aid agencies to ensure that aid is not wasted through duplicating each others work

Following best practices requires additional time and higher administrative costs.

Aid agencies often disregard best practices in order to provide quicker and cheaper aid. Although this  saves money for the individual agency, thereby pleasing donors, it leads to greater overall wasted aid, promotes graft and fraud, can lead to unnecessary aid, and can cause aid not to reach those that need it the most.

With no regulating body to enforce best practices, pleasing donors has become the overriding factor in aid agency success. Aid agencies that are effective at fund raising, regardless of the quality of their projects, will prosper and grow. Aid agencies that are ineffective at fund raising, regardless of quality of their projects, will falter and die.

Better donor practices will lead to better aid practices

The economic advantage gained by overlooking industry standards outweighs the programmatic benefits of following best practices. Aid practices will only improve when donor reward best practices.

aid agencies best practices donations donors wasted aid

Article by: GoodIntentions

GoodIntentions was a blog about international philanthropy hosted by Saundra Schimmelpfennig between 2009 and 2012. Ms. Schimmelpfennig is a distinguished veteran of more than 20 years in the international relief and development field, including four years working in Thailand following the 2004 tsunami. She is founding director of The Charity Rater and was also founding director of the Disaster Tracking Recovery Assistance Center.

Previous Story“Sexy” projects are easier to fund Next StoryChoosing the right aid agency can be a daunting and frustrating task
You may also like these posts
Here’s How To Plan Your Giving For The 2017 Hurricane SeasonMomos for Nepal

Leave A Reply: Cancel Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  1. Pingback: Good Intentions Are Not Enough » Blog Archive » Mosquito Nets and Recycling August 13, 2010

    […] Related posts: The allure of the quick fix 6 questions you should ask before donating goods overseas Best practices often lose out to quick and cheap programs that please donors […]

  2. Dan W Log in to Reply

    amen, amen, amen. "Aid agencies that are effective at fund raising, regardless of the quality of their projects, will prosper and grow. Aid agencies that are ineffective at fund raising, regardless of quality of their projects, will falter and die." Sad but true. The majority of our donors are individuals and religious institutions who have a heart for the issues facing Zambia. Most would emphasize their willingness to be sacrificial in their participation in our work. I have begun to ask our partners if they would be willing to sacrifice their "timeline" or "horizon" if it meant the difference between long term benefit and short term gain. Their ongoing partnership will be the answer to the question.

  3. Pingback: Mosquito nets and recycling | Good Intentions Are Not Enough January 2, 2012

    […] Related posts The allure of the quick fix 6 questions you should ask before donating goods overseas Best practices often lose out to quick and cheap programs that please donors […]

Recent Posts

  • Here’s How To Plan Your Giving For The 2017 Hurricane Season
  • Momos for Nepal
  • In Minnesota, Rep. Keith Ellison Spreads the Word about Diaspora’s Role in Humanitarian Response
  • Disaster Survivors Don’t Need Bottled Water
  • Send cash, not stuff, to help the world’s refugees
  • Good Intentions Hinder Response to Canada’s Wildfires
  • Here’s How to Plan Your Giving for the 2017 Hurricane Season
  • Practice Smart Compassion for Hurricane Preparedness Week

WHAT WE DO

  • USAID Activities Reports
  • Situation Report ListServ
  • Media
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

YOU CAN HELP

  • Hotline Volunteering
  • Donations Registry
  • Commodities
  • Technical Assistance
  • USAID CIDI Toolkit

Find us elsewhere

Copyright © 2017 USAID Center For International Disaster Information